Here’s a question I ask almost every small business owner who runs their own Google Ads: of all the conversions in your account, which one is an actual booking?
Most people can’t answer straight away. Not because they don’t know their business, but because the account has collected conversion actions over the years. Someone installed a phone-click tag. The booking software added its own events. A plugin started sending form submissions. Each one made sense at the time.
Then they all end up counted the same way, and Google Ads optimizes toward whatever is cheapest to get.
What I keep seeing in real setups
This week I sent notes to a few local businesses after looking at their sites from the outside. Two examples stood out.
A massage studio. Their Tag Manager sends three different conversion actions to Google Ads. From the site code alone I couldn’t tell which one is a booked massage and which might be a page view or a button click. If all three count equally, Google gets told “a click on the booking button” is worth the same as “a paid appointment.”
A gym. Their Tag Manager has several Google Ads conversion tags, and the event list includes website form submissions, landing-page form submissions, phone clicks, and the booking software’s register, booking and purchase events. That’s at least six signals. Only some of them mean “a person signed up for a trial and is likely to show up.”
I can’t see how either account weights those actions from the outside. That’s exactly why I ask. But this pattern is common: when every action is primary, the campaign learns to find people who click “call” and hang up, not people who become members.
Primary vs secondary, in plain words
Google Ads lets you mark each conversion action as primary or secondary.
- Primary conversions are the ones your bidding learns from. They show up in the “Conversions” column, and Smart Bidding (Maximize Conversions, Target CPA and so on) uses them to decide who to show your ads to and how much to bid.
- Secondary conversions are tracked for observation. You can still see them in the “All conv.” column, but bidding doesn’t optimize toward them.
So the question isn’t “should I track phone clicks?” Track them. The question is whether they should steer the budget.
My rule of thumb: primary is the action closest to money that happens often enough to learn from. For a service business that’s usually a confirmed booking or a qualified lead form. Button clicks, page views and “started checkout” are usually secondary.
The count setting: one vs every
There’s a second setting that quietly inflates numbers: whether a conversion counts one per ad click or every time it happens.
I’ll use my own site as the example. In the last 90 days, PostHog recorded 82 clicks on my booking buttons from 41 people. That’s two clicks per person on average. People click, look at the calendar, come back later, click again.
If I imported “booking button click” into Google Ads as a primary conversion set to count every time, my account would report twice as many conversions as there were interested people, and none of those clicks is a confirmed booking.
My booking thank-you page shows the same thing. Each person who reached it in the last 90 days loaded it about four times on average (refreshes, coming back to the confirmation, opening it from another tab). A “page view of the thank-you page” conversion set to every would overcount by roughly four times.
For leads and bookings, “one” is almost always the right choice. “Every” makes sense when each repeat is real value, like separate purchases in an online store.
A 20-minute check you can do today
Open Google Ads, go to Goals, then Conversions, and look at the summary. For each conversion action, answer four questions:
- What actually triggers it? A button click, a page load, a form submit, a call over a certain length, a purchase? If you don’t know, check Tag Manager or the booking tool’s integration settings.
- Is it primary or secondary? Write down which ones are primary. If there are more than two or three, be suspicious.
- Is it set to count one or every? For leads and bookings, it should usually be one.
- Is it recording at all? Look at the status column. An action that has been “No recent conversions” for months but is still primary can confuse reporting.
Then make the call: keep one or two primary actions that represent real bookings or qualified leads, and move the rest to secondary. You don’t lose any data. You just stop asking Google to optimize for the wrong thing.
One more thing to check while you’re in there. While going through a batch of local business sites, I found one gym loading tags for two different Google Ads accounts on the same site. If that’s you, make sure you know which account your campaigns run in, and that its conversions are the ones being counted. Otherwise your data is split, and neither account sees the full picture.
What changes after you fix it
Be ready for the numbers to look worse before they look better. When you move button clicks and page views to secondary, your “Conversions” column drops, sometimes a lot. Your cost per conversion goes up. That’s not the campaign getting worse. It’s the account telling the truth for the first time.
Give Smart Bidding a couple of weeks to relearn before you judge it, and judge it on bookings you can see in your own calendar or CRM, not just the Google Ads column.
If you also run Meta ads, the same logic applies to the events you optimize for. A campaign optimized for “Lead” learns from whatever fires that event, so make sure it fires on a real submission, not a page load.
When you want a second pair of eyes
This is one of the first things I check when someone books time with me, because everything else (bidding, budgets, keywords) depends on it. If the conversions are wrong, every optimization after that is built on sand.
If you’d like to go through your conversion list together, a Power Hour is usually enough to sort out what’s primary, fix the count settings and agree on what “a conversion” means for your business. If you want help rebuilding the setup and launching campaigns with your team, the 4-session pack covers diagnosis, planning, launch and a review of the first results.