When I look at a small business website before a call, the first thing I do is open the page source and search for tracking codes. Lately one result keeps coming up on Squarespace sites: an old Universal Analytics tag, the kind that starts with UA-.
Google stopped processing Universal Analytics data in 2023. A site that still loads a UA- tag sends hits to a property that no longer records anything. The code runs, nothing breaks, and nobody notices, because there’s no error message. The reports just stop.
Here’s what I found, why it matters if you plan to run Meta or Google ads, and the 15-minute check I’d do on your own site.
What I found on 72 Squarespace sites
Over the last few weeks I’ve reviewed the public homepage code of 150 small business websites, mostly local service businesses: massage studios, tutors, swim schools, landscapers, designers. 72 of them were built on Squarespace.
On 14 of those 72 Squarespace sites, the homepage still loads a Universal Analytics tag.
This morning I rechecked all 14. Every one of them still loads the UA- tag today. On 12 of them, the tag is loaded the way Squarespace’s own Google Analytics integration loads it, so it most likely comes from an old ID saved in the site’s settings. The other 2 run the old analytics.js snippet, which someone must have pasted in by hand years ago. Either way, somebody connected Google Analytics once, it worked, and nobody touched it again.
The rest of the picture on those 14 sites:
- None had a Google Analytics 4 measurement ID (the
G-code) in the homepage code. - 3 also load Google Tag Manager. GA4 could be running through Tag Manager on those, and I can’t see that from the outside, so I’m not counting them as broken.
- 2 have a Meta pixel.
- None has a Google Ads tag.
One example made it concrete for me. A massage studio takes bookings through Acuity and sells gift certificates. The only tracking code I could find on its site was the old UA- tag. Going into gift card season, that site may not be recording visits, bookings or gift certificate sales anywhere.
A fair caveat: many of these businesses don’t run ads, so a dead tag isn’t costing them ad money today. It becomes a problem the day they start.
Why a dead UA tag matters before you run ads
If you’re not running ads, a dead analytics tag means you’re flying without a dashboard. Annoying, not urgent.
If you’re about to run ads, it matters a lot more, for three reasons.
You think you have tracking, but you don’t. The most common thing I hear is “we have Google Analytics set up.” The owner remembers setting it up, so it never makes the to-do list. The UA tag is the reason the question never gets asked.
You have no baseline. Before you spend anything on ads, you want to know how many visits, bookings and enquiries the site gets on its own. Without it, you can’t tell whether the ads added anything or just took credit for people who would have booked anyway.
Ad platforms can’t optimize for something they can’t see. Analytics and ad tracking are separate. GA4 alone won’t tell Meta or Google Ads which clicks turned into bookings. But a site with a dead UA tag almost never has the ad side set up either. On these 14 sites, none had a Google Ads tag and only 2 had a Meta pixel.
The 15-minute check
You don’t need a developer for this. Open your homepage in a desktop browser and work through it.
1. Search your page source for UA- and G-
Right-click the page, choose “View Page Source”, and search (Ctrl+F or Cmd+F) for UA-. Then search for G- followed by letters and numbers.
- Only
UA-: your analytics stopped recording in 2023. G-present: GA4 is loading. Good, move on.- Neither, but
GTM-present: you use Google Tag Manager, so check inside Tag Manager what it actually fires.
2. Find where the old tag comes from
On Squarespace, the UA- tag usually comes from the Google Analytics field in your site settings, where an old ID was saved years ago. Squarespace moves its menus around, so if you can’t find it, search their help center for “Google Analytics”. If your source shows ga('create', 'UA-... instead, the old code was pasted into code injection, so look there and remove it.
3. Set up GA4 and confirm it records
Create a GA4 property in Google Analytics, copy its G- measurement ID, and connect it to your site. Then open your site on your phone and check GA4’s real-time report. If you see yourself, it works.
4. Make sure the action that matters is tracked
Pageviews aren’t the goal. Decide which one action is a real lead for you: a booking, a quote request, a gift card purchase, a phone call. If that action happens in another tool, like Acuity, Vagaro or Jobber, check whether that tool can send events to GA4 and your ad platforms, and test it with a real booking.
5. Add the ad tags before the first campaign
If you plan to run Meta ads, install the Meta pixel and check it in Events Manager. If you plan to run Google Ads, add the Google tag for your Ads account and set your booking or lead as the primary conversion. Do this before the campaign goes live, not after the first week of spend.
What this looks like when it’s done right
The goal isn’t more tags. It’s one clean answer to one question: of the people who clicked my ad, how many booked?
On a well set up site, a test booking shows up in GA4, in Meta Events Manager and in Google Ads within minutes. If yours doesn’t, that’s where I’d start, before touching targeting, creatives or budgets.
Want a second pair of eyes?
If you’d rather go through this together, book a Power Hour. We’ll open your site, check what’s actually firing, and leave the call with a clear list of what to fix before you spend on ads. If you want help setting up tracking and launching your first campaigns with your team, the 4-session pack covers diagnosis, planning, launch and the first review.