Conversion tracking

Duplicate Google Ads Tag? I Checked 8 Active Advertisers and 3 Had Tags Loading Twice or Clashing

By Francesco Ambrosiano / / 5 min read

When a Google Ads account “suddenly” shows more conversions than the business actually got, or the numbers in Google Ads never match Google Analytics, the first thing I check isn’t the campaigns. It’s the website.

Last week I looked at 8 local businesses whose ads were live on Google, confirmed in the Google Ads Transparency Center (last shown Nov 4–5). A roofer, a chiropractor, a family law office, a med spa, a physical therapy clinic, a plumber, an HVAC and plumbing company, and a tutoring company. This morning I rechecked every homepage and the public Google Tag Manager file each one loads.

Here’s what came back.

What I found on 8 sites running Google Ads

So 5 of the 8 had something in their Google tag setup that I’d want to fix or at least explain before trusting the conversion numbers.

The three ways tags end up doubled

1. The same tag in the page and in Tag Manager

The physical therapy clinic loads the same Google Ads ID and the same Google Analytics ID twice: once pasted directly into the page, and again inside its Tag Manager container.

This usually happens innocently. Someone installs the Google tag from the Google Ads setup screen. Later, someone else (or the same person a year on) sets up Tag Manager and adds the tags there too. Nobody removes the first one.

The risk depends on how each copy is configured. Sometimes Google handles it fine. Sometimes a conversion fires from both, and every booking counts as two. You can’t tell from the page source alone, which is why the check below uses Tag Assistant.

2. Two Tag Manager containers loading the same thing

The tutoring company goes one step further. Its Google Ads ID is in the page and in one Tag Manager container. A second Tag Manager container also loads, and both containers fire the same Google Analytics ID. Then there’s a third, different Analytics ID on the page.

That’s three layers of tracking on one homepage. If you’ve ever looked at a report and thought “these page views look high,” this is often why.

3. Two different Google Ads IDs

The chiropractor has one Google Ads ID pasted in the page and a different Google Ads ID inside Tag Manager.

Two IDs means one of two things:

Either way, the account that’s bidding can be learning from incomplete data. Google’s Smart Bidding decides who to show your ads to based on the conversions it sees. If half of them land somewhere else, it’s optimizing on a partial picture.

The setups that aren’t duplicates but still cause trouble

Tag in the page, Tag Manager empty of ads tags. The med spa has its Google Ads tag hard-coded and Tag Manager installed with no Google Ads tag inside. That’s not double counting. The problem is practical: when someone later adds a conversion in Tag Manager (the usual way to track a “Book Now” click), it may not connect to the tag that’s already on the page, or they’ll add a second Google Ads tag and you’re back to problem #1.

Google Ads with no Analytics. The plumber runs its Google Ads tag through Tag Manager and has no Google Analytics at all. Ads can still track conversions, but you lose the second opinion. When Google Ads says 20 calls and you think it was 8, Analytics is how you find out which page, device or source the gap comes from.

Different pages, different containers. On Nov 5 the roofer’s contact page loaded a different Tag Manager container from the homepage, and that one had no Google Ads tag, so form leads from the contact page may not have been counted. When I rechecked this morning, the contact page loads both containers. Someone may have fixed it, or the setup changes by page. That’s the point: the homepage isn’t the only page that matters. Check the page where the lead actually happens.

Why this matters more than it looks

Bad tags don’t throw errors. The ads keep running, the dashboard keeps showing numbers, and everything looks fine. The damage is quiet:

I’d rather find this before someone spends another month of budget on top of it.

A 15-minute check you can do yourself

  1. Open your site and view the page source (right-click, View Page Source). Search for AW-. Write down every Google Ads ID you see. Then search for G- (Google Analytics) and GTM- (Tag Manager).
  2. Count the Tag Manager containers. More than one GTM- ID is a flag. It’s not always wrong, but someone should be able to tell you why.
  3. Look inside Tag Manager. Open each container and list the Google Ads and Google Analytics tags. Compare them with what’s hard-coded in the page. Same ID in both places means you should remove one.
  4. Match the Google Ads ID to your account. In Google Ads, go to Goals > Conversions, open a conversion action, and look at the tag setup. The AW- number there should match what’s on your site. If your site has an ID that isn’t in your account, find out whose account it is.
  5. Run Google Tag Assistant (tagassistant.google.com) on your site, then do the real action: submit the form or click Book Now. Watch how many times the conversion fires. One action should mean one conversion.
  6. Repeat on the page where leads happen. Contact page, booking page, quote page. Not just the homepage.

If you find two Google Ads IDs and nobody knows where the second one came from, don’t delete anything yet. First confirm which account is spending money, then remove the other.

Want a second pair of eyes?

This is one of the first things I check in a Power Hour: we open your site, your Tag Manager and your Google Ads account together and make sure one booking means one conversion, in the right account. If you’d rather fix the tracking and then build the campaigns properly with your team, that’s what the 4-session pack is for.

Related

Sold outFunnel Forge — build your entire marketing funnel in 4 live sessions. Every cohort is full. Join the waitlist →