Last week I looked at 16 businesses that were actively hiring someone to run their Meta or Google Ads. Online stores, med spas, roofers, a yoga studio, a SaaS tool, a supplement brand.
Before anything else, I ran a simple conversion tracking audit on each site: which tags load, where the conversion happens, and whether the ad platforms can see it.
15 of the 16 had at least one problem. 13 of those I could confirm straight from the page code; the other 2 need a check in a real browser to be sure.
None of this is about bad ads. It’s about the platforms learning from the wrong signal, or none. Here’s what came up, most common first.
How I ran the audit (and what it can’t see)
I only looked from the outside: the page source, the Tag Manager containers that load publicly, the scripts in the site bundle, and where the “Book” or “Buy” buttons send people. I also checked the Meta Ad Library to see who was already running ads.
An outside check can’t see settings inside the ad accounts, like which conversions are primary. So read everything below as “likely problem, go confirm”.
Pattern 1: The conversion happens on someone else’s website (5 of 16)
This was the most common one, and the most expensive.
A spa books through Vagaro. A med spa uses Zenoti. A yoga studio links out to Mindbody. A facial bar franchise uses Boulevard and its own app. A SaaS company sends signups to a separate web app with no tracking at all.
The pixel and Google tag on the main site see the visit and maybe the click on “Book now”. They don’t see the booking, because it happens on another domain. So the platform optimizes for people who click a button, not people who pay.
How to check: do a test booking yourself. Note every domain you pass through. If the final confirmation page isn’t on your site, find out whether your booking tool has a setting for your Meta pixel or Google Ads conversion (many do), or whether it can redirect to a thank-you page on your domain that you can track.
Pattern 2: Planning Google Ads with no Google Ads tag (4 of 16)
Four businesses said they wanted to run Google Search, Performance Max or Google Ads with conversion tracking. None of the four had a Google Ads tag on the site. One roofing company had no Google tracking of any kind: no Google Ads tag, no GA4, no Tag Manager, and I checked the JavaScript bundle too, not just the HTML.
One store had Tag Manager installed, but the container was empty. It loads, it looks set up, and it does nothing.
How to check: open your homepage, View Page Source, search for AW-. No result means no Google Ads tag on that page. If you use Tag Manager, open the container and confirm it actually contains tags and that it’s published.
Pattern 3: Duplicate tags and duplicate accounts (4 of 16)
- One kitchenware store loads tags for two different Google Ads accounts, an older one and a newer one.
- One pet food store loads two separate GA4 properties plus two more Google tag IDs.
- One nail studio has two Tag Manager containers. One has no tags at all; the other holds only GA4.
- One franchise loads GA4 twice, once directly and once through Tag Manager.
Duplicates either count conversions twice, so cost per result looks better than it is, or split them between accounts, so the account that’s spending never learns from the purchases.
How to check: search your page source for AW-, G- and GTM-. More than one ID of the same type is a question you need to answer. Then in Google Ads, confirm which account is spending and that it has a primary purchase or lead conversion that’s recording.
Pattern 4: A dead Universal Analytics tag still loading (4 of 16)
Four sites still load a Universal Analytics tag (the UA- ones). Google stopped processing data for standard Universal Analytics properties in July 2023. A supplement brand running hundreds of Meta ads still has one in its Tag Manager. So does a med spa group with several locations.
The dead tag doesn’t break anything by itself. But it means nobody has reviewed the tracking in years, and other things are usually stale too: old conversion actions, old audiences.
How to check: search the source for UA-. If it’s there, open Tag Manager and remove it. Then look at what else in the container nobody has touched since then.
Pattern 5: No tracking at all, or tracking off by default (3 of 16)
- A day spa had started running Meta ads days before I looked, with no Meta pixel, no GA4 and no Tag Manager on the site. Bookings go through a third-party tool, so nothing is measured anywhere.
- A med spa hiring someone to run both Meta and Google had no pixel, no GA4, no Tag Manager and no Google Ads tag on its homepage.
- A skincare brand’s cookie banner script revokes Meta consent by default, and its TikTok pixel is set to disabled. If that applies to US visitors too, Meta could be seeing a fraction of real purchases. This is one I flagged as “verify in a browser”.
The one that was fine
One roofing company’s tracking looked fine. Its problem was the job description: one person expected to run Google, Meta, Local Services Ads, YouTube, SEO, social, content and recruiting. When one person covers everything, the basics get skipped.
A 15-minute conversion tracking audit you can run yourself
- Test the full path. Click your own ad or your homepage CTA and complete a booking, purchase or form. Write down every domain you pass through.
- Search your source. On the homepage and the final confirmation page, search for
fbq(Meta pixel),AW-(Google Ads),G-(GA4),GTM-(Tag Manager) andUA-(dead). - Count the IDs. One of each is the goal. Two of anything needs a reason.
- Open Tag Manager. Confirm the container has tags and the latest version is published.
- Check the platforms. In Meta Events Manager and in Google Ads conversions, look for your test conversion. If it didn’t show up, the platform can’t optimize for it.
- Compare with reality. Take last month’s conversions in the ad platform and compare with real bookings or orders in your system. If they’re way off, fix that before touching bids, budgets or creative.
Why this matters more than the ad
If the tracking is wrong, a new hire spends their first month optimizing toward the wrong thing, and the reports look fine while it happens.
If you want to go through your own setup with me, live in your accounts, that’s what a Power Hour is for. If you’d rather fix tracking and then build the campaigns on top of it together, the 4-session pack covers both.