Retargeting

Retargeting Window: How Long Should Your Retargeting Audience Be? (What 40 Booking Clicks on My Site Told Me)

By Francesco Ambrosiano / / 5 min read

When I set up retargeting for a client, one of the first questions is how many days to keep visitors in the audience. 7 days? 30? 180? Most people pick a number because a course or a template used it.

I wanted an answer from real behavior, so I looked at my own site. Over the last 180 days, how long did people take between their first visit and clicking the button to book a call with me?

What my data shows

I pulled this from PostHog, the analytics tool on adsformakers.com. I left out traffic from China and Spain and a few US data-center cities, because earlier checks showed that traffic is mostly bots or my own visits.

40 people clicked a booking button in the last 180 days. Here’s how long it took them, counted from the first visit PostHog can see:

Then I looked at a softer signal: people who opened one of my offer pages. 69 people did that in the same period. 59 did it on the day of their first visit. Of the other 10, 5 came back within a week, 4 came back after 18 to 23 days, and 1 came back after 34 days.

Two things stand out.

Most people decide fast. If a visitor is going to act, they usually do it in the first session. That matches what I see on client accounts: the landing page does most of the work, and retargeting is a second chance, not the main event.

The late ones are real, and a short window misses them. With a 7-day audience, 2 of my 3 late bookers would have already dropped out of the audience when they came back. With a 30-day audience, 1 would have. Among the offer-page viewers, a 7-day window would have missed 5 of the 10 people who came back.

A few honest caveats

This is a small site with small numbers, so treat it as a pattern, not a law.

Your numbers will be different. A $40 product and a $15,000 kitchen remodel don’t have the same decision time. That’s exactly why it’s worth checking your own data before you pick a number.

What the platforms let you do

Meta (Facebook and Instagram): a website custom audience can keep people for 1 to 180 days. You set this when you create the audience in Audiences, and you can make several audiences from the same pixel with different windows.

Google Ads: website visitor segments (your data segments) have a membership duration you set yourself, up to 540 days.

So the platforms aren’t the limit. The limit is usually budget and audience size. A small business with a few hundred visitors a month can’t split them into five tiny audiences and expect any of them to deliver well.

How I’d choose a retargeting window for a small business

Here’s how I set it up with clients who run their own accounts.

1. Check your own decision time first. In GA4, PostHog or whatever you use, look at people who converted (booked, called, bought) and see how many days passed since their first visit. You don’t need a perfect report. Even a rough split of “same day”, “within a week”, “within a month” and “later” tells you a lot.

2. Start with one audience that covers your real decision time. For most local service businesses I start with 30 days, and go to 60 or 90 if the purchase is big or the data shows late returners. Then I check how big the audience is. If it’s too small to spend the budget, I make the window longer, not shorter.

3. Exclude people who already converted. This sounds obvious, but I keep finding retargeting campaigns that show “Book your free consult” to people who booked last week. On Meta, exclude a custom audience built from your booking or lead event. On Google Ads, exclude converters through your conversion-based segment or customer list.

4. Split by time only when you have the volume. If your traffic supports it, a short window (for example 1 to 7 days) and a longer one (8 to 60 days) can get different ads. People who visited yesterday need a nudge and an easy next step. People who visited a month ago need a reminder of who you are, plus proof: a review, a before-and-after, a short video.

5. Show something new. Someone coming back after three weeks has already seen your main ad. Showing it again is a wasted impression. Use retargeting for the answers they were missing: price range if you can share it, how the process works, what happens on the first call.

6. Make sure the pixel or tag actually records the first visit. All of this depends on tracking. If your Meta pixel only loads after a cookie banner, or your Google tag is missing from the landing page, the visitor never enters the audience. No window length fixes that.

The short version

My own data says most people act within minutes, and a few come back weeks later. A 7-day window catches the first group and loses most of the second. For a small business, one well-sized audience of 30 to 90 days, with converters excluded and ads made for people who already know you, usually beats a complicated setup.

If you want help setting this up in your own account, book a Power Hour and we’ll pull your decision time and build the audiences together. If you’d rather work through retargeting, tracking and creative over a few weeks, the 4-session pack gives us time to set it up and check the results between calls.

Related

Sold outFunnel Forge — build your entire marketing funnel in 4 live sessions. Every cohort is full. Join the waitlist →