Ad copy

Your Best Offer Is on Your Website. Why Isn't It in Your Ad?

By Francesco Ambrosiano / / 5 min read

Earlier I wrote about Facebook ads that promise an offer the website doesn’t show. This week I kept running into the opposite problem, and I think it’s more common: the website has a clear, specific offer, and the ad doesn’t say a word about it.

I went through live ads from local businesses in Google’s Ads Transparency Center and Meta’s Ad Library, then opened each website. Five of them had a concrete deal, a price or a “specials” section on the site that the ad either left out or only hinted at. I rechecked three of those sites this morning and the offers are still up.

Here’s what I found, what it costs you, and how to check your own ads in about ten minutes.

What I found on 5 live advertisers

All businesses anonymized:

Five out of five isn’t a statistic, it’s a pattern I kept seeing while doing other checks. But these are real businesses paying for clicks this month.

Why a vague ad costs you more than you think

Someone searching “furnace replacement” in November is comparing three or four contractors at once. Every ad on that page says “free estimate,” “family owned,” “financing available.” The one that says “0% for 60 months, ends Nov 20” gives them a reason to click that one and not the others.

When the deal only lives on your website, three things happen:

  1. Fewer of the right people click. The person who’d be swayed by 0% financing never learns about it unless they happen to click you first.
  2. You pay for the curious instead of the ready. A generic ad attracts everyone, including people who bounce the second they see a price they didn’t expect.
  3. Your best work is wasted. Somebody sat down and built that offer, the page and the countdown. Then the ad, which is the only part most people ever see, ignores it.

On Facebook it’s even more direct. Nobody is searching for you there. The ad has to earn the stop in the feed, and “New Patient Special” without the special is asking people to click to find out. Most won’t.

How to check your own ads in 10 minutes

You don’t need any tools for this. Open your ads in one tab and your website in another.

Step 1: Write down every offer on your site

Go through your homepage, your main service pages and any Specials, Promotions or Financing page. List every concrete thing: a price, a discount, a financing term, a free item, a deadline. If it’s in a banner or a pop-up, it counts.

Step 2: Read your live ads, word for word

In Google Ads, look at the headlines and descriptions of your active responsive search ads, and check which assets Google actually shows most. In Meta Ads Manager, read the primary text and headline of every active ad. If you want to see them the way a stranger does, look yourself up in the Ads Transparency Center or the Meta Ad Library.

Step 3: Match them up

For each offer on your list, ask: does at least one active ad say it in plain words? “Financing available” isn’t the same as “0% for 60 months.” “Special” isn’t the same as the special.

Step 4: Check the deadline

If the offer ends on a date, your ad should either mention the date or be scheduled to change when it ends. An ad still promising a November deal in December is its own problem.

Step 5: Check where the click goes

If the ad is about one treatment or one service, it should open the page for that treatment or service, where the offer is visible without scrolling. Not the homepage.

Where to put the offer

Google Ads: write the offer into at least one or two headlines, and consider pinning one so it actually shows. Google also has promotion assets, which let you show a discount or a deal for an occasion like Black Friday under your ad, with start and end dates so it switches off on its own.

Facebook and Instagram: put the offer in the first line of the primary text and in the headline. People read the first line and the image. If the offer isn’t in one of those two places, assume nobody sees it.

Both: make sure the same number appears on the page the ad opens. If the ad says one price and the page says another, people start wondering which one is real.

One thing to check before you add the offer

If you’re going to make your ads sharper, make sure your account can tell which ads produce leads or bookings. One of the med spas above had no Google Ads conversion tag I could find. Without one, Google can’t tell whether the new offer-led ad brings in more bookings than the old one, so you’re judging it on clicks.

That’s the order I’d go in: tracking first, then the offer in the ad, then the landing page.

Want a second pair of eyes?

This is the kind of thing I go through in a Power Hour: we open your ads and your site side by side, find where the message breaks, and fix it on the call. You leave knowing how to do the check yourself next time.

If you want help building the whole thing properly, with tracking, campaigns and landing pages, and want to learn to run it yourself, that’s what the 4-session pack is for.

Related

Sold outFunnel Forge — build your entire marketing funnel in 4 live sessions. Every cohort is full. Join the waitlist →